2 / 20
Which propeller configuration results in the best handling characteristics if a light twin suffers a left hand engine failure after departure from runway 36? The reported wind is 270°/10 kts.
  • A
    Counter rotating propellers.
  • B
    Clockwise rotating propellers.
  • C
    Engines mounted on the side of the fuselage.
  • D
    All have the same control problems.

Refer to figure.

Asymmetric blade effect (also known as ‘P’ Factor)

Propeller blades are not flat, they are in fact shaped as small wings. As a consequence, as the angle of attack of the airplane increases, the air passing by hits the blades differently:

The down-going blade (viewed from the cockpit) will have a larger angle of attack compared to the up-going blade, generating more thrust. This then means that the down-swinging blade exerts a greater force than the up-going blade. For this reason, the thrust line will be displaced to the right of the engine centre line.
  • Propellers rotating in the same direction (clockwise): if both engines rotate clockwise, the right engine will have a longer thrust arm than the left engine. This difference in thrust will give a yawing moment to the left with a clockwise rotating propeller in a nose-up attitude. The failure of the left-hand engine will result in a larger yaw effect via the operating right-hand engine, rather than vice-versa. The left engine is therefore the critical engine.
  • Counter-rotating propellers: they are called counter-rotating propellers because the propeller on one wing turn in the opposite direction to the one on the other wing. The principle advantage of counter-rotation is to balance propeller torque effects thus eliminating any problems associated with a Critical engine.
=> For both counter-rotating inwards or outwards, the yawing moment will be the same regardless if the right or left engine fails. However, for a counter-rotating inwards propeller, the yawing moment will be smaller than that for a counter-rotating outwards propeller. The down-going blade for the counter-rotating inwards will be in the inner side and, consequently, the thrust vector will be close to the CG; whereas for counter-rotating outwards propellers, the down-going blade will be in the outer side, resulting in a longer thrust arm and larger yawing moment.

Your Notes (not visible to others)



This question has appeared on the real examination, you can find the related countries below.

  • Austro Control
    2
  • Sweden
    1